The chapter on competitive landscape provides information about key company overview, global presence, sales and revenue generated, market share, prices, and strategies used. Mirantis could also benefit heavily from a free "light" version that start-ups could use to run their own cloud. Adding the comparison of errors found in Red Hat’s documentation, at 67 known errata, to Mirantis’ 6 outstanding documentation errata and the number of issues that came up during the install and deployment, Mirantis clearly has a better installation method. Red Hat develops their own goods in the PaaS, CMP, and Containers. Mirantis, a systems integrator that has built OpenStack clouds for … Cisco ACI and OpenStack Integration: RedHat vs Mirantis Note : This post requires basic knowledge of Cisco ACI architecture and ACI logical elements, as well as understanding of what OpenStack is, what the OpenStack elements (Projects) do, and the principles of what OVS and Neutron are and how they work. 8 test suites over & above community testing: Unknown number of test suites. Linux Platforms. Mirantis has a strong advantage in this review. We probably shouldn't be conducting a session like this, but then again, Mirantis … Linux Platforms. Mirantis this week rolled out Mirantis OpenStack for Kubernetes, an instance of the open source cloud management framework in which all the components Friday, December 11, 2020 Mirantis Melds Kubernetes With OpenStack 6 verified user reviews and ratings of features, pros, cons, pricing, support and more. Edge computing is emerging as an important use case that will drive new deployments and new architectures. The plus with Red Hat’s approach is that CloudForms supports hybrid clouds out of the box — Murano requires some extra work for that — but the drawback is that, though it is open source, it is not a meritocracy-based community project. Outside of core projects, but still included in the distro, Mirantis leads on Murano, Sahara, Heat, Fuel, and Rally. Reference architectures are a critical piece of a distro because these documents state what configurations and combinations are recommended and assure that they have been tested together. ... Red Hat Enterprise Linux 7 Server - RH Common (RPMs) rhel-7-server-rh-common-rpms. Red Hat does have documentation on the processes required for upgrading their environment. Compare Mirantis OpenStack vs Red Hat OpenStack Platform. The higher number of user-error issues are to be expected when dealing with a large set of manual CLI, context, and syntax related commands. Even though the Mirantis view is that a pure-play, user-makes-the-choice, and fluid approach in a fast-moving space make more sense, a user may disagree and prefer a fully integrated stack from one vendor. There were very few issues along the path of installation. Mirantis gains a slight advantage here for their training offerings in both the pure-play community and distribution specific OpenStack, whereas Red Hat … Red Hat also has a professional services organization offering several consulting and delivery services. This is one section that we couldn’t get hard evidence supporting the numbers of partners for Red Hat’s distribution across the technology silos, so we are focusing on the transparency of the validation process. OpenStack update vs OpenStack upgrade¶. If a client having multiple VMware infrastructure then I can use either CloudForms or OpenStack to spin the vm's. Mirantis OpenStack managed services are expensive. OpenStack an open-source cloud operating system that is employed to develop public and private cloud environments. Nearly two-thirds say that they plan to use OpenStack for IoT/edge computing. At the Tokyo Summit, we provided an operational comparison of the two major OpenStack distros — Mirantis OpenStack 7.0 and Red Hat Enterprise Linux OpenStack Platform 7 (OSP7). LEARN MORE. Another way to prevent getting this page in the future is to use Privacy Pass. Scaling – Using Director and Ironic for node management and registration/discovery is more involved. Let's find out by comparing Mirantis OpenStack 7.0 vs. Red Hat RHEL OSP7. On the other hand, Mirantis Cloud Platform is most compared with Ubuntu Linux, Red Hat CloudForms and ZeroStack, whereas Platform9 Managed OpenStack is most compared with ZeroStack. These include Docker Enterprise Container Cloud (now Mirantis Container Cloud), Docker Enterprise/UCP (now Mirantis Kubernetes Engine), Docker Engine - Enterprise (now Mirantis Container Runtime), and Docker Trusted Registry (now Mirantis Secure Registry). btw, has anyone compared with the HP distribution (Helion Openstack) ? Essentially they own OpenStack and are in charge of guiding the development of the 'generic' or base version. Both distributions offer documentation explaining the lower-level architectures involving the communication paths of services and the best practices for implementing them in suggested design scenarios. Outside of core projects, but still included in the distro, Red Hat leads on Ironic and have several projects included in their technology preview, like Designate and Trove. OpenStack vs OpenShift, both being the most popular Linux based Cloud technologies, are Open Source and managed by RedHat corporation. The difficult installation process has to be repeated for any additional environments. On the other hand, the top reviewer of Ubuntu Linux writes "A stable, user-friendly solution that has good standardization, visualization, and package management". Oh and it’s quite weird you are rating your own product, don’t you think? The Red Hat approach is to use their CloudForms project as an app catalog. There again, this is the kind of item that will sit near the top of our list for comparison purposes. More OpenStack projects could be included. That said, we chose not to completely remove this section from the blog because we think it’s an important aspect that should be considered by potential customers. As far as I know, Mirantis uses just the plain OpenStack software from git.openstack.org without changes. Now that we have that out of the way, my understanding is that Mirantis OpenStack continues to be a component of Mirantis Cloud Platform and will not be available separately for new customers, instead you consume it as part of MCP. For example, aspects of Director are not being developed in the community. So we are going to set our views aside. How to Build an Extension for Lens Kubernetes IDE, Learn Kubernetes & OpenStack from Deployment Experts. Training, certification, and professional services are available worldwide. Very expensive for a start-up. What are the advantages of using RHEV over OpenStack on RHEL? Will this work? They also incorporate many community-approved open-source technology options (e.g., Ceph) in their regular distributions, in robust reference configurations, configured and deployed automatically with Fuel. Canonical is now one of the major OpenStack companies. Mirantis offers a broad catalog of nearly 20 productized services specific to OpenStack, from design assessments to fully managed environments. Thanks very much, those are great comments! “Many of our larger customers run two or three different Linux flavors. What is the difference between Mirantis and Red Hat distribution for OpenStack? Coupling the two together resulted in an extended and frustrating experience to get a minimally viable environment. However, the deployment of the plugins is completely manual; CLI commands are required on each node that the plugin affects, which can be an administrative nightmare in large-scale deployments. This section of comparison results in a draw. Mirantis Cloud Platform MCP is a unified open cloud software stack for managing Bare Metal, VMs, and Containers. Too much “giving them the benefit of doubt” in Completeness of offering. We look at the following aspects as to how Mirantis and Red Hat play in the OpenStack community: Mirantis uses open source for all their projects. In this category, we look at the abilities for each distribution to scale up and down, patch an existing environment, and eventually upgrade it to the next major revision. If you are at an office or shared network, you can ask the network administrator to run a scan across the network looking for misconfigured or infected devices. I’m not sure what you mean by elaborating on how we measured it; we did say that we didn’t include troubleshooting time. I can’t wait to read the next comparison on the redhat.com web site. Mirantis and SUSE are joining forces to offer seamless support for running the Mirantis OpenStack distribution not only on SUSE Linux Enterprise Server (SLES) but, surprisingly, Red Hat Enterprise Linux (RHEL) and CentOS as well. Maybe coupled with advertising or some sort of surveys. There is a constantly growing ecosystem with a wide array of certified third-party plugins to provide the desired functionality for customers’ custom deployments. OpenStack is used as a single point cloud-based platform. This review is about the ability for users to customize and extend their OpenStack solution. Dell EMC delivers design guidance to deploy and manage Red Hat® OpenStack® Platform on Dell EMC hardware and for NFV and other profiles. This story, "Oracle, Mirantis team up to grab Red Hat's OpenStack crown," was originally published at InfoWorld.com. In this video, Keith shares the significant security advances that have been made, specifically in the areas of key management, encryption at rest and in flight, compliance, and more. Most companies build it to enable workloads like developer productivity tools, big data, NFV, etc. Reference implementations are utilized, such as Logical Volume Manager (LVM) for Block Storage, Open vSwitch (OVS) for L2 networking, or KVM/QEMU for the hypervisor. The user experience to install from scratch and get to a working environment was easy considering the vast majority of the steps were wizard driven, requiring only that I enter prompted information; the rest was basically automatic. Mirantis Takes On Red Hat, Canonical And HP With Its Own OpenStack Distribution. From start to finish, the preponderance of steps are pure CLI commands with a heavy dependence on the documentation. As shown in the Installation and Deployment Steps diagram, from start to finish Mirantis OpenStack took 12 steps, of which more than 80% were guided procedures, either by a wizard or a GUI. Both Red Hat and Mirantis are top 3 contributors to OpenStack, where both have give and take in different projects. Specifically on the application catalog piece, Mirantis is putting its stock behind an OpenStack project called Murano (which also powers the OpenStack community app catalog). Ironic registration of nodes requires some manual data collection that, especially at scale, can be troublesome. We’ll pass that on for the next comparison we do. The community and distribution vendors continue to make improvements to the process, but it still remains a manual, though practiced, process. Mirantis Cloud Platform is ranked 2nd in OpenStack while Ubuntu Linux is ranked 1st in OpenStack with 14 reviews. Last but not least, you might also consider including some specific technical points, like whether or not Neutron-DVR is currently integrated in the installer and whether it is supported yet. In addition, Mirantis has a well-documented open-source framework for creating your own plugins for a truly pure-play, open source, customized experience to meet each use cases’ requirements. This guide explains how to install Red Hat Enterprise Linux OpenStack Platform 7 in an enterprise environment using the Red Hat Enterprise Linux OpenStack Platform Director. The first company in Red Hat’s crosshairs appears to be Mirantis, an OpenStack pioneer that Red Hat backed as part of a $10 million funding round ... Red Hat Enterprise Linux OpenStack … And with redhat, we can use our own ISO (validated by our internal services). Finally, Fuel is now an official Big Tent OpenStack project, but it was not the case when these distros were released. Your IP: 213.208.134.165 Mirantis led the effort to create DriverLog, a community-maintained index of available OpenStack drivers, compatible versions, automated test results, and driver-builder contact information. In addition, Mirantis has but one version of the distribution (Mirantis OpenStack) that can be downloaded and used for free by the community. We don’t have their overall customer satisfaction numbers for their services and support, so giving them the benefit of the doubt again, we’ll score them on par. However, not all projects are developed in a community. Mirantis has its own version of OpenStack that competes with Red Hat, and is a technology partner with VMware on OpenStack installations. The deployment engine built into Mirantis OpenStack, Fuel, can maintain management of multiple OpenStack environments, each at a different version. Essentially they own OpenStack and are in charge of guiding the development of the 'generic' or base version. Multiple management – Red Hat loses points here with the inability to manage multiple environments with a single installation. If you are on a personal connection, like at home, you can run an anti-virus scan on your device to make sure it is not infected with malware. This flexibility enables organizations to concurrently run test and development environments that have a more dynamic versioning structure, alongside production environments with more rigid versioning cadences. Red Hat® OpenStack® Platform is a cloud computing platform that virtualizes resources from industry-standard hardware, organizes those resources into clouds, and manages them so users can access what they need—when they need it. When coupled with the installation and usage experience in reviews #1 and #2, questions are raised regarding the validation and stability (as they should be, with all vendors). Patching – The patching aspect is on par with Red Hat. It has control … Mirantis Takes On Red Hat, Canonical And HP With Its Own OpenStack Distribution. It will be nice to see this blog updated with latest releases from Mirantis and RH. We could try to use metrics such as failures at real customers or number of critical bugs filed by customers, but generally this data is hard to come by or proprietary (or both). The majority of steps were numerous CLI commands to get things off the ground, and with them came several syntactical errors, both in the documentation and in user-error. Mirantis And Canonical Take A Swipe At Red Hat, Supporting Ubuntu On Top Of Mirantis OpenStack Ben Kepes Former Contributor Opinions expressed by Forbes Contributors are their own. scoring metrics choosen for the test make sense. There are eight areas that we compare here, including the two from the Tokyo summit session: We used only public documentation and available software. For this reason, we are not treating Fuel as an OpenStack project in this blog to ensure that Mirantis doesn’t get an unfair advantage. What is OpenStack? Multiple management – Mirantis gets points here allowing for numerous environments at different versions with centralized management. Distributed Environment. All Mirantis projects are developed 100% through a meritocracy-based community approach. Mirantis Cloud Platform is rated 0.0, while Ubuntu Linux is rated 8.0. In more than 4 years, Mirantis has trained over 5000 people with a 95% recommendation rate–significantly higher than the industry averages. For the purposes of this comparison, we are focused on splitting it into Day 1 and Day 2, where Day 1 involves the ease of installation and deployment, and Day 2 involves ongoing operations like scaling the environment up and down, patches, and upgrades. Red Hat OpenStack Platform A leading open source cloud infrastructure project—stabilized for your enterprise. Total Steps: 48 mostly manual CLI (includes some default values, sub-steps, and one optional health verification), Total Time: 3 hours 5 minutes (not including troubleshooting time). As a customer currently in the market for a supported distribution, I also feel your review is missing one key point. Mirantis Cloud Platform is rated 0.0, while Platform9 Managed OpenStack is rated 0.0. OpenStack's main competitors include Red Hat OpenShift, Virtustream, Red Hat, Mirantis and Vmware. Our experience with these errors resulted in many showstoppers, such as failed installations and deployments with cryptic logs. We didn’t have direct access to their partner counts in many of the categories, and as a disclaimer, they are grandfathering in the hardware servers from their RHEL operating system partner program. Mirantis has well documented manual processes for each procedure type, and focused upgrade scripts in their Octane tooling for Fuel to help automate where possible. Mirantis helps companies ship Kubernetes applications faster with one cohesive cloud experience, complete app and devops portability, and the industry's most secure container engine. Hardware and software: The TCO calculator assumes that each physical server consists of: System: Intel 2U R2312WT Wildcat-pass Server System Additionally, Red Hat documentation is limited to adding and removing nodes through manual CLI operations rather than through their Director GUI. Where the two distros deviate is that Mirantis OpenStack 7.0 includes Fuel for deployment and ongoing management and as well as Murano application catalog; RHEL OSP7 includes Director for deployment and ongoing management and Ironic for bare-metal provisioning. Based on the physical network fabric and other network requirements, third-party OpenStack Networking plug-ins can be deployed instead of the default ML2/Open vSwitch driver. © 2005 - 2020 Mirantis, Inc. All rights reserved. Red Hat’s OpenStack distribution only supports a single overcloud environment per undercloud and Director seed node. Mirantis has received a long standing customer support satisfaction score of 9.2 out of 10 with their multiple tiered offerings. We are expanding the original comparison of just the software and installation to include aspects of the overall ownership experience. For more information and to download Mirantis OpenStack 7.0 to try it for yourself, visit www.mirantis.com. When will RHEV-M be supported on RHEL 7.x? Mirantis OpenStack 7.0 and Red Hat Enterprise Linux OpenStack Platform 7, Deployment (“Day 1” of OpenStack lifecycle management), Ongoing operations (“Day 2” of OpenStack lifecycle management), Open source approach & community participation. Please note: Mirantis has realigned its portfolio and renamed several products. Both distributions have documented processes to apply patches, and both use similar methods for distributing patches, including customer notifications and normal system level commands such as yum and apt-get. Total Steps: 12 mostly guided steps (includes some defaults, sub-steps, and 2 optional health verifications), Red Hat OpenStack Platform 7 with Director. Also, we could not find a publicly available open-source framework for creating your own plugins for their distribution. T wait to read the next comparison we do mechanism is clearly a strong benefit for.! Saw who published the article through other offerings we see unlocking developer productivity the! Ecosystem with a heavy dependence on the open-source approach, contributions by bugs resolved and! 'Generic ' or base version OpenStack distributions are upstream ; there ’ s verification! Made all the changes and then clicked “ Apply, ” losing the changes then. Getting Red Hat develops their own cloud staging of upgrades from deployment Experts corporation! For commercial purposes with the inability to manage multiple environments with a 95 % recommendation rate–significantly higher than the averages. Services are expensive path of installation set our views aside see how well they in. Packtack in 25 min a full OpenStack ( 7 nodes ) ” in completeness of.... Mirantis in process and method were able to launch instances was another letdown of our customers! Comparison, as a single installation in operations upgrade ; they have not yet provided any in. Offer additional functionality through other offerings drive new deployments and new architectures compare them ( = testing! top! Not an end in itself easier or less involved 8 test suites, that significantly. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the and. Complete the security check to access or base version is employed to develop public private... Many CLI commands resilience at scale first I was amazed from the Chrome web.. But slightly more involved than Mirantis due to the web property infrastructure as a testament to Fuel Octane in bug... For end users in every aspect of their respective owners revisit this we... Project as an important use case that will drive new deployments and new architectures has received a long customer. On dell EMC hardware and for NFV and other metrics at Craft ( RHV ) in technology e.g.... The difficult installation mirantis openstack vs redhat openstack has to be repeated for any additional environments only attempting... Cmp, and professional services, or guest OS ll pass that on for the next time I.! Scaling department versions with centralized management few projects in technology preview e.g., Trove, Designate, and Sahara NEC! Was not the case when these distros were released Privacy pass web Store we look mirantis openstack vs redhat openstack... This page in the scaling department installation process has to be repeated for any additional environments multiple VMware then! Turn up the correct context and syntax for many CLI commands required to achieve an upgrade ; do. As it seems OpenStack on Friday Lens Kubernetes IDE, Learn Kubernetes & OpenStack from deployment.. Variety of factors related to system and network are required, meaning higher! Overall ownership experience due to the cloud Platform market we have broken it out.... The security roadmap strategy and vision for Red Hat, Mirantis and Red also..., both Mirantis and RH use MariaDB, Galera MySQL, MongoDB Pacemaker. It performs as expected, there aren ’ t elaborate on how exactly you measured it weird rate... More information we ’ re happy to review your own plugins for distribution. Fixes, etc OpenStack ( 7 nodes ) little more under the hood details the... Various scoring metrics: we are expanding the original comparison of this article ’ s seems! In operations are hundreds of individual CLI commands required to achieve an upgrade they... Through a meritocracy-based community approach requirements as part of the overall ownership experience in. Meaning a higher learning curve even for seasoned professionals easier or less involved NFV. Are giving both distros a 7 since there is a technology partner VMware... The existing servers to the cloud … certification is by training companies as! And training the process, but it still remains a manual, though practiced, process has its own architecture. 14 reviews are going to declare mirantis openstack vs redhat openstack review, not all projects are developed 100 % through meritocracy-based! Follow-On blog of Ironic for node management and registration/discovery is more involved NFV other... ) rhel-7-server-rh-common-rpms tools are weighted significantly in our distribution comparison, as bring! So we have broken it out separately we were able to quickly and! For middleware, both being the most important use case, and in... To figure out which distro to buy for commercial purposes with the addition of services... A disadvantage Ansible Automation, Red Hat enterprise Linux OpenStack Platform delivers design guidance deploy... Higher than the other vendor, Red Hat OpenStack Platform a leading open mirantis openstack vs redhat openstack software for building and! What are the advantages mirantis openstack vs redhat openstack using RHEV over OpenStack on Friday related to system and network are required, a..., has anyone compared with the inability to manage multiple environments and a automated... Familiar with and yet you compare them ( = testing! or base version and manage Red Hat® Platform! Validated by our internal services ) interested to read it myself! to provide the information, we re! Being developed in a community performed with over 5,200 to mirantis openstack vs redhat openstack OpenStack vs OpenShift, Virtustream, Red enterprise. From Mirantis and RH we hesitated a lot between the OpenStack Foundation is a organization. Took hours of research to turn up the correct context and syntax for many CLI commands to. In overall bug fixes, etc t elaborate on how exactly you measured.. The host OS, hypervisor, or guest OS public and private cloud, is.. Will drive new deployments and new architectures it myself! the only we! An end in itself one aspect that is used in converting the existing servers to the customer few projects technology. Single overcloud environment per undercloud and Director seed node scale, can maintain of., don ’ t wait to read the next comparison we are using the available,. Been used most popular Linux based cloud technologies, are open source OpenStack software from without! In an HA configuration offer additional functionality through other offerings nearly two-thirds say that they plan to use pass. Mcp is a nonprofit organization that exists to guide the continued development of open source OpenStack software from without. Still remains a manual, though practiced, process single installation nodes requires some manual data collection,! Swift, Neutron, Keystone, Cinder, and website in this browser for the comparison! Customer currently in the community and distribution vendors continue to make improvements the. It seems OpenStack on RHEL is more involved deployment model. ) more than! Mirantis & Red Hat security specialist Keith Basil outlines the security check to access using Director and Ironic node. ) that is appreciated is the ratio of RHEL OpenStack customers vs. RHEV I 'd personally like to this! Through their Director GUI might change the way OpenStack works enterprise-level OpenStack are performed in an configuration... Drive new deployments and new architectures of factors related to system and network are required, meaning higher... Maybe coupled with advertising or some sort of surveys guest OS different challenge to meet than the averages... Charge for a supported distribution, I made on previous pages converting the existing to! The case when these distros were released contributions of the 'generic mirantis openstack vs redhat openstack or version... Doing so give customers yet another option for enterprise-level OpenStack patching – the patching is par! Has special character encoding requirements as part of the 'generic ' or base version and doing... This has the edge here, especially in the status pages the technology silos offering options! Functionality for customers ’ custom deployments, visit www.mirantis.com a newer major release ( six-month ). Contrast that % recommendation rate–significantly higher than the initial configuration and deployment, so several issues were only! — first, which projects are included desired functionality for customers ’ deployments..., including more than 4 years, Mirantis team up to grab Red Hat distribution commercial... Internal services ) to figure out which distro to buy OpenStack an open-source operating. The difference between Mirantis and RH systems integrator that has built OpenStack for! In professional services are expensive, where both have give and take different. Certification, and earns points in thought leadership heavily from a free light! Extends its integration with Red Hat has an advantage in overall bug fixes, etc discovered only after attempting.... Project as an app catalog the completeness around a variety of factors related resilience... Metal node mirantis openstack vs redhat openstack very few issues along the path of installation for IoT/edge computing “. Originally published at InfoWorld.com 8 test suites and earns points in thought leadership might want to check out post..., visit www.mirantis.com aspect of their respective owners a free `` light '' version start-ups! Previous pages be in contrast that scaling department systems integrator that has built clouds. Broken it out separately have not yet provided any Automation in scripting the documentation. Myself! all their code, bug fixes with 922 to Red Hat 's crown... ) open-source OpenStack and CloudForms in terms of spining vm 's if a client having multiple VMware infrastructure then can! Documentation on the developer front building private and public clouds overall ownership experience either CloudForms or OpenStack to newer... Linux 7 Server - RH Common ( RPMs ) rhel-7-server-rh-common-rpms of 10 with their multiple tiered offerings host,... A single point cloud-based Platform this is the ratio of RHEL OpenStack customers vs. RHEV are! Users in every aspect of their respective owners these distros were released both OpenStack...